FAIL comparing gyre_nad.txt - ref/gyre_nad.txt.x86_64-Darwin

[keatonb]

Hi Rich/anyone,

I ran into trouble running the standard tests on my new installation of Gyre 3.0. As requested I am posting my trouble here. Please see the error message below and let me know if you can suggest a solution.

Thanks so much!
Keaton Bell

[mesasdk] Keatons-MacBook-Pro:gyre keatonb$ make test
make[1]: Entering directory `/Users/keatonb/gyre/test'
make[2]: Entering directory `/Users/keatonb/gyre/test/ad'
TEST homogeneous compressible model (analytic structure) ...succeeded
TEST homogeneous compressible model (polytropic structure) ...succeeded
TEST homogeneous compressible model (OpenMP) ...succeeded
TEST MESA model for beta Cephei star ...succeeded
TEST MESA model for RGB star ...succeeded
TEST MESA model for slowly pulsating B-type star ...succeeded
make[2]: Leaving directory `/Users/keatonb/gyre/test/ad'
make[2]: Entering directory `/Users/keatonb/gyre/test/nad'
TEST MESA model for beta Cephei star ...succeeded
TEST MESA model for slowly pulsating B-type star41c41
< 1 -2 0 2 0.1704644003609259E+01 0.3177697533438574E-08 0.2600445176696146E-08
--- field 5 relative error 7.09e-14
> 1 -2 0 2 0.1704644003609138E+01 0.3177725785488805E-08 0.2600445173448801E-08
102c102
< 2 3 3 0 0.6328780885532442E+01 0.5862766833102780E-02 0.5861702565389363E-02
--- field 5 relative error 5.53e-14
> 2 3 3 0 0.6328780885532092E+01 0.5862766833152430E-02 0.5861702565389994E-02
104c104
< 2 5 5 0 0.8641943221611337E+01 0.4629364476224432E-01 0.4628612000217709E-01
--- field 5 relative error 5.73e-14
> 2 5 5 0 0.8641943221610841E+01 0.4629364476146798E-01 0.4628612000213882E-01
...failed when comparing gyre_nad.txt and ref/gyre_nad.txt.x86_64-Darwin
make[2]: Leaving directory `/Users/keatonb/gyre/test/nad'
make[1]: Leaving directory `/Users/keatonb/gyre/test'

[rhtownsend]

Hi Keaton --

(Welcome aboard!)

This is probably because you're using a slightly different SDK than the one I ran the tests with. At some point, I plan to make the code bit-for-bit reproducible (as Bill Paxton recently did with MESA). In the meantime, given that the errors are 1 part in 10^14, I don't think there's too much to worry about!

cheers,

Rich

[keatonb]

Thanks Rich!

I wasn't too alarmed, but you did request that I post any failures so I did. Thanks for making this code available!

Keaton